Tier cakes people remember long after the party.
Since 1913, Taylor's Bakery has been part of Indianapolis celebrations for generations. From weddings to anniversaries, showers, birthdays, and milestone celebrations, our tier cakes are known for timeless beauty, classic buttercream artistry, and the kind of flavor that makes people go back for a second slice.
Founded
1913
Four generations of Indianapolis families have trusted Taylor's for the cakes at life's biggest moments.
WeddingWire rating
4.9 / 5
Backed by 84 reviews and a 98% recommendation rate from couples who have already celebrated with Taylor's.
Wedding services
Consultation, design, delivery
From weddings to anniversaries and milestone birthdays, the process is built to feel easy, polished, and dependable.
Indianapolis tier cakes
A bakery families already love, for weddings and every other big moment worth celebrating.
Legacy
Family owned
Style
Classic buttercream
Service
Delivery & setup
Why people choose Taylor's
This is the centerpiece, the photo moment, and one of the best bites of the celebration.
The cake is beautiful in photos, but the flavor is what has guests talking long after the reception is over.
Taylor's style is timeless for a reason: elegant buttercream work, graceful details, and cakes that never feel trendy for trend's sake.
There is comfort in choosing a bakery Indianapolis families have loved for generations, because trust matters for weddings and every other big celebration.
The experience feels personal and reassuring from the start, so planning your tier cake becomes one of the fun parts of the process.
Reviews & reputation
People don't just love how these cakes look. They love how Taylor's makes the whole experience feel.
WeddingWire snapshot
84 reviews • 98% recommended
WeddingWire couples consistently mention the same things: beautiful presentation, delicious cake, warm service, and a bakery they felt good trusting with such an important day.
WeddingWire
Couples come back to the same themes again and again: beautiful cakes, delicious flavor, and a team that makes everything feel easy.
Google reviews reinforce what locals already know: Taylor's is dependable, welcoming, and consistently excellent at custom cakes.
Taylor's has the kind of hometown loyalty you cannot fake, with generations of customers who already know the name and trust the work.
Tier cake gallery
Tier cakes made to feel right at home at beautiful celebrations.
From classic white tiers to floral buttercream designs, every cake is created to feel celebratory, elegant, and unmistakably special the moment it is brought into the room.
Classic elegance
Scrollwork buttercream wedding cake
Statement design
Pillared wedding cake with draped detail
Reception favorite
Classic round buttercream reception cake
Soft florals
Garland tiered cake with buttercream flowers
Bold florals
Cascading floral wedding cake
Grand celebration
Grand tiered cake with dramatic floral accents
Frequently asked questions
The details people usually want to know before they book.
If you already know your date, location, and approximate guest count, you are in a great place to start the conversation.
How much do tier cakes cost?
Tier cake servings start at $6.50 per serving and go up from there depending on the number of tiers, design details, and overall complexity.
How much is delivery and setup?
Delivery and setup are available for $53. We can confirm timing and logistics with you based on your venue or event location.
How much lead time do you need?
We recommend at least one week of lead time whenever possible so we can give you the best finished cake. If you need something sooner, still reach out. We can often move faster depending on the date and design.
Do you offer consultations for tier cakes?
Yes. You can book a consultation right on this page through Calendly, or send an inquiry form and our cake team will follow up with you.
Can you help us choose servings and design?
Absolutely. We can help you think through guest count, tier sizes, overall look, and the best way to balance budget, style, and serving needs.
How far in advance should we book?
The earlier the better, especially for popular dates. Reaching out as soon as you have your date and venue helps make sure we can reserve your spot.
Book the next step
Let's create the cake everyone talks about.
Tell us about your date, guest count, style, and location, or book a consultation right on this page. Whether you are planning a wedding or another special occasion, we'll help you design a tier cake that feels like the perfect fit and tastes every bit as good as it looks.
Reserve your consultation time
Pick a time that works for you, and we'll start planning the tier cake your guests will remember.
Prefer to open Calendly in a new tab?